Searching for God # 155
In the last post here, a montage of excerpts from different religious perspectives seemed to have some overlap in that all acknowledged a vision, image, opportunity and/or invitation to imagine, as well as to incarnate a different ‘world’ from the one humans on earth have been living in for centuries. Circumnavigating (or should that be superceding? or rising above?) all specific religious faiths, the concept poses a significant issue for us mere humans: the paradox of living ‘within’ the contemporary culture, whenever and wherever, while aspiring to a ‘new’ life also there and then. If we begin with the feasibility, credibility, veracity and “God-centred” nature of such a proposition, we can acknowledge that a sine qua non of such a transformation, whether in personal, familial, organizational or even national terms, is something many have called the ‘creative imagination.’ And not only has it been so labelled, it has also been considered be a link, a common trait, or even an identifying legacy of/from/with God.
Not attempting to wade into the empirical, or even the philosophical argument about some ‘ethereal,’ ‘ephemeral,’ or even ‘mystic,’ discourse to prove some divine or sacred powers or association between God to the creative imagination, let’s try a much more limited, lay-person, probably for many a more pedestrian perspective to parse any hypothetical association between God and the creative imagination. After reconciling with the literal, empirical, scientific, sensate and ‘basic needs’ aspects of our lives, we then almost intuitively and inexplicably wander off into more esoteric questions like “why am I, or anything else, here?’ or ‘is there something after death?’ or ‘what comprises the good life?’ or ‘how do we know, perceive, recognize evil?’ or ‘what is this thing called sin?’ And while there are the equivalent of ‘data centres’ filled with words, pictures, dogma, myths and rituals that all attempt to ‘answer’ such unanswerable enigmas, nevertheless, our own individual imagination, almost without our conscious awareness wanders into those waters often when we least expect it. Irrespective of what formal education or professional training or skill development we might already have acquired or attained, such questions take on a kind of ‘energy’ perhaps in a series of images or pictures, perhaps unconsciously out of some anxiety, or aspiration.
For centuries, images of dark beasts and heavenly angels have populated the myths, novels, plays and cultural rituals as we dip into, extrapolate from, shun, or even emulate or imitate those images. Today is October 16, and in the Western culture, there is an evening at the end of this month we call Halloween, imaginatively populated with ghosts, goblins and other ‘fantastic’ creatures from the compendium of the universal collective, creative imagination. What, if anything, does that ‘celebration’ have to do with any iteration of a theology?
For centuries, humans have participated in a kind of ritualistic, tribalistic, incarnation of those forces over which we have neither control nor profound and convincing empirical information. Gods and goddesses, beasts from the animal world, have all been imbued with traits for which we have obsessively aspired and just as obsessively feared. Mythic gods and goddesses, for example, have been said to have been engaged in both the most creative and loving acts as well as the most heinous and despicable and hateful acts. Their names and individual narratives, in various cultures, have penetrated the cognition as well as the collective imagination of the people who both told and absorbed those stories and then considered them integral to whatever and however they ‘defined’ ‘perceived, ‘valued,’ and ‘perpetuated,’ what they called ‘life.’
Northrup Frye reminds us that literature is comprised basically of two different kinds of dreams: utopian and dystopian. And they are based on those images we imagine as our most favoured, admired and inspiring on the one hand, and also those images from which we attempt to escape or to fear, or with which we seek to engage in combat or at least some kind of conflict.
Supplementing our literary, social, and public discourse about such images, (aside: not to mention any influence we might have absorbed from religious ‘teachings’ or indoctrination), we all have impertinent, involuntary, irrascible and highly engrossing dreams. These ‘images’ that ‘float’ onto the screens of our unconsciousness, with a frequency and an unscheduled and unappointed timing, become for some merely ‘distractions’ from the responsible literal, duties to which we have been committed. For others, they may become puzzles worthy of deep probing in and through dream analysis. For still others, those images linger, disappear, re-appear, confuse, confound, intrigue and often perplex us for some time. As we are unable to ‘nail down’ a specific interpretation or meaning, they continue to ‘present’ as ineffable, ephemeral, inexplicable, unknowable and inscrutable conundrums.
And here is where a kind of elision of images, dream images, monster images, mythic deity images and some kind of evolving, ever-changing, deepening or superficial (depending on our individual experience, learning and world view) image of God continues to flow or fluctuate. Just as our dreams ‘curate’ and give voice to ‘images’ attempting to portray something (whatever it might be, not necessarily some moral axiom, as some would prefer), an analogy might apply to our gestation of the/a/our deity. Dream images cannot be defined by empirical science, nor by cognitive principles, nor religious dogma, doctrine or expectations, nor necessarily by psychological theories; neither can our ‘conception’ of God.
As some have said, if there were no God, we humans would have to ‘invent’ one. Whether there might be life ‘out there’ in the universe’ remains an object of much scientific exploration and theorizing. There can be no doubt about the life ‘in there’ in our dreams, our imagination, our unconscious (both collective and individual) and potentially in what some (perhaps even many) call our spiritual life. Shaw originated the line, now cliche, about how some people see things as they are and ask why? while others see things as they might be and ask why not? Two different kinds of ‘seeing:’ the first, a literal, empirical, scientific, pragmatic, utilitarian “reality” open to and responsive to intervention; the second, (seeing how things might be) is poetic, imaginary, elusive, extraordinary, beyond here and now, somewhere out there.
As humans we live as inheritors, exemplars, balancers and embodiments of both kinds of seeing. Our public world emphasizes, if not operates exclusively on the literal, empirical, scientific, pragmatic kind of ‘seeing, ‘perceiving,’ ‘analyzing,’ ‘comparing,’ ‘competing,’ ‘building,’ ‘changing’ and ‘believing,’ We believe that a rock if dropped from our hand will inevitably and predictably fall to the ground. There are zillions of similar apparently indisputable ‘facts’ which were once considered theories. These days, some quantum physicists are positing the idea that not matter but consciousness is the connecting concept, notion, abstraction, force, energy that holds the universe in some form of ‘togetherness.’ Having spent millenia exploring the options and risks of the former ‘theory’ that matter was the uniting component, are we likely to spend several more millenia exploring the ‘consciousness’ theory? And after that, perhaps will be entering a phase in which a theory that posits that unconsciousness, or dreams, or the ephemeral, ineffable, unknowable deity is our most likely mutually inter-and-intra-connecting synapse?
Or is the religious impulse, the homo religiosus, as Karen Armstrong puts it, already extant, living, breathing and interacting with various kinds of advocates and opponents here and now.
Armstrong is enlightening in her book, The Case for God, in the chapter entitled ‘homo religiosus’ where we read:
In archaic thinking, there is no concept of the supernatural, no huge gulf separating human and divine. If a priest donned the sacred regalia of an animal pelt to impersonate the Animal Master, he became a temporary manifestation of that divine power. These rituals were not the expression of a ‘belief’ that had to be accepted on blind faith. As the German scholar Walter Burkett explains, it is pointless to look for an idea or doctrine behind a rite. In the premodern world, ritual was not the product of religious ideas; on the contrary, these ideas were the product of ritual. Homo religiosus is pragmatic in this sense only: if a ritual no longer evokes a profound conviction of life’s ultimate value, he simply abandons it. But for twenty-thousand years the hunters in the region, (Lascaux Caves in France) continued to thread their way through the dangerous pathways of Trois Freres in order to bring their mythology—whatever it was—to life. They must have found the effort worthwhile or they would without a backward glance, have given it up. Religion was not something tacked on to the human condition, an optional extra imposed on people by unscrupulous priests. The desire to cultivate a sense of the transcendent may be the defining human characteristic......Before the modern period, most men and women were naturally inclined to religion and they were prepared to work at it. Today many of us are no longer willing to make this effort, so the old myths seem arbitrary, remote and incredible. Ike art, the truths or religion require the disciplined cultivation of a different mode of consciousness. The cave experience always began with the disorientation of utter darkness, which annihilated normal habits of mind. Human beings are so constituted that periodically they seek out ‘ekstasis,’ a stepping outside the norm. Today people who no longer find it in a religious setting resort to other outlets: music, dance, art, sex, drugs, or sport. We make a point of seeking out these experiences that touch us deeply with and lift us momentarily beyond ourselves. At such times, we feel that we inhabit our humanity more fully than usual and experience an enhancement of being. (pps.9-10)

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home