Searching for God # 156
Truth, love, beauty, ekstasis, transcendence, metanoia, sacrifice are all concepts, notions and even aspirations deeply inextricably, and permanently associated with the Christian faith. New ‘birth,’ and ‘new life,’ and ‘aha,’ and even ‘filial fear’ as a holy inclination of the heart generated by God in humans....these also are intimately, and both consciously and unconsciously intertwined with many of the stories of the New Testament. Christians ‘celebrate’ the eucharist or Mass, in remembrance of the Last Supper in the recorded life of Jesus of Nazareth. Humble honouring is an integral and essential feature of authentic discipleship, follower. Christians ritually conducted baptism services for new-born children and for new members of the Christian community of faith. The Christian church has sacralized the ritual of both confirmation and holy matrimony. Even the wrapping of the clergy stole around the hands of both bride and groom symbolically represents the embrace, sharing joining and unifying of God with this union. Upon death, the Christian church offers a funeral ritual as a symbolic and reverent celebration of thanksgiving for the life of the deceased and for the promise, hope and aspiration and for many conviction of another unity, of the soul of the deceased with the heavenly Father in and for eternity.
In addition to the formal rituals, the ‘church’ also engages in various forms of ‘loving support’ of the sick, the elderly, the lonely, the homeless, the grieving, and, to the degree and extent feasible, the dispossessed in foreign lands. Some of this outreach is also designed for and delivered to those whose lives have foundered on addictions, divorce, job loss, and various forms of natural and human-inflicted violence. Coherent, cogent theological theory and praxis over centuries have attempted to maintain, sustain and enhance the image of LOVE....of God of all creatures everywhere and always.
The totality of this ‘institutional’ historic, revered, even sanctified bolus of practice, thought and narrative, including the narrative of myth, has for millenia and continues today to encourage, embrace, sustain and develop the spiritual lives of millions around the globe, albeit with a plethora of nuanced and often quite divisive differences in both theory and praxis.
The basic fundamental theological premise that, as Paul reminds us, we have all sinned and come short of the glory of God, has for many, been a defining trait in which we have been born and from which we require release, redemption and salvation, all available only in and through the grace of God. Not all world religions, fortunately, have adopted that premise. Nevertheless, what is impossible to refute, reject, deny or avoid is the psychological also inherent human trait that both good and evil are inextricably and unavoidably interwoven into the life of each individual human being.
Karen Amstrong, in what amounts to a curation of much theological thought, in her book The Case for God, writes:
The Eden story is not an historical account; it is rather a description of a ritual experience. It expresses what scholars have called the coincidentia oppositorum in which, during a heightened encounter with the sacred, things that normally seem opposed coincide to reveal an underlying unity. In Eden, the divine and the human are not estranged but are in the same ‘place’: we see Yahweh ‘waling about in the garden at the breezy-time of the day; there is not opposition between ‘natural’ and ‘supernatural,’ since Adam is animated by the breath of God himself.
In many Christian churches and communities, this ‘coincidentia oppositorum’ has been turned into a faith obsession, expression, expectation and even requirement that ‘sin’ or ‘evil’ is contrary to the will of God and needs, requires, and even demands ‘retribution, punishment, and deliverance from’ through what has come to be known as another of the church rituals, the penitential, confessional, conventionally linked to the promise, aspiration and delivery and reception of forgiveness, grace and release, all premised on the sacrificial death of Calvary.
Personalized ‘sin’ seems also to have been deliberately separated from institutional and/or social/systemic/structural evil. Civil, criminal as well as ecclesial ‘courts’ are prepared to administer what is termed ‘justice’ or ‘love’ to/for those whose deeds have been alleged/charged/defined as miscreant. Public opinion is the single, and highly amorphous, ill-defined, and irresponsible ‘court’ for which no specific, concerted, collaborative and judicial action is expected, although the gestalt of its impact may indirectly impact the thought and decisions of other formal court entities.
It is into the body of public opinion that non-religious theory, whether scientific or perhaps less formally cognitive and socially confirmed ‘common sense’ based on the recurring patterns of human behaviour is hourly, daily annually and cumulatively ‘stewed’. As the moral arbiters of social opinion and behaviour, the churches themselves have studiously and scrupulously avoided, and to some degree escaped, the kind of legal and criminal prosecution that is applied to the secular society. Nevertheless, there is a growing public consciousness of a human proclivity for both risk and evil, with which we (collectively, collaboratively, universally and resolutely) have failed to take ‘account’ and ‘responsibility.’
To observe that the churches, almost imperceptibly and unconsciously, have played and continue to play a part in this avoidance, denial, rejection of and blindness to the human proclivity for risk and evil seems a somewhat trite redundancy because it is so obvious. Indeed, for many, especially those imbued with and seemingly drowning in a sea of obsession with and need for testosterone (alpha males) and perhaps those whose adulation for such males remains unbridled.
It continues to be a matter of considerable urgency and perplexity that the moral code, both written and understood, seems to embody and even reinforce the binary separation of good from evil in our public consciousness. Indeed, once an individual has been ‘dubbed’ (not even alleged or charged with a complaint or a misdemeanour or a civil or criminal charge) ‘evil,’ or ‘wrong’ or ‘abusive’ or ‘dangerous,’ or ‘too risky’ or ‘bad company,’ that stain will, like a permanent tattoo, never really be excised, erased, forgotten or lifted. The scapegoat of the garden of Eden, the snake is an archetype for which we have failed to make appropriate individual and collectivel accommodation. Armstrong’s attribution for the snake seems to fall short. She writes:
In the snake is the rebelliousness and incessant compulsion to question everything that is crucial to human progress. (The Case for God, p. 28-29) It seems that another of our human proclivities is to judge others, willy-nilly, without taking account of what we might be ‘doing’ (permanently, impunitively, and unconsciously, especially of our psychic need for power and dominance gained abusively and unjustly and unfairly by demeaning and disdaining others. Blaming ‘the other’ if and when we are found out in malfeasance, is easily borrowed, stolen and applied in and through the archetype of the ‘innocent’ animal.’
It is not a stretch to observe the human ‘judging obsession, proclivity, habit, need, wish, negative aspiration’ behaviour in which we all engage, especially rampant among churches and their most righteous, social-and-ethical-and-moral-purity-addicted self-righteous, is implicitly and complicitly embedded in the very social, cultural, political, academic, and scientific ‘evil’ of, at one end of the continuum, mere gossip, and at the other character assassination.
There is a ‘thrill’ aspect to both our proclivity for risk-danger, and to our obsessive-compulsive engagement in negatively demeaning others. We are engaged in ‘on-the-edge' emotions of both testing the combativeness of another as well as the strength of our own convictions, without having to pay a price directly. Social media has transformed this human proclivity for risk and abuse into a zillion-dollar profit-making behemoth. Indeed, based on the thinking of Gerard about imitation, it can be considered an appetite for which there is no satiation for individuals and no limit to the social and greed-dependent limits of its profitability. From this perspective, we humans have now wrought ourselves on the horns of our own petard.
We cannot and will not deviate from, disown, or even acknowledge our absolute dependence on our insatiable appetite for aggressively, imaginatively and incessantly seeking out, finding and then executing some plan to ‘take another down’ as a demonstration of our power, strength, invincibility, and social status. And we will also refuse, reject, deny, avoid, and destroy any and all attempts to rein in what might be considered one of the most heinous and reprehensible of all human traits. It is as if, to borrow, a template from the 12-step program, we have become dependent on an aspect of our own human psychic identity and incapable on our own, either individually or collectively, to ween ourselves off this obsessive-compulsion. And we acknowledge, admit and share our need for God’s help in releasing us, both individually and collectively, from this ‘slavery’ to our own sabotaging nature.
Have we come to a place where it is now both literally and metaphorically impossible for any human being to deny his/her personal and social enmeshment in this highly emotionally addictive and obsessively-compulsive trait? We can try to separate ourselves from the most odious perpetrators, (think Oval Office, for example) and both say and think that we are not like him. Or, we can acknowledge that some are willing to be so blatant and repulsive in the deployment of character (and culture, and institution, and tradition, and conventional morality and norms) that this behaviour greets us every time we go before a mirror.
And the churches can no longer bury their institutional head in the sand of denial, avoidance, blindness and hubris, and separate the institution, as well as the theology of socially and politically ‘correct’ deportment from being considered either a mirror or a lamp on the expectations, aspirations, dreams and fantasies of God. The churches (from decades of direct, personal experience) are undeniably and indisputably industrial-sized agents of human desecration, demeaning, with abusive and both unsupported and exaggerated and venemous judgements up to and including excommunication, deposition, dismissal and refusal to access the sacraments. The premise of perfection as an idealized attribute of God demanding human imitation is not only a theological misrepresentation of God; it is also dramatically unsustainable on any level, personal, familial, institutional or national.
The cohabitation of good and evil, as a reality, has been displaced by an exclusive, binary, either-or, ascension of the good over evil, sanctioned, by, endorsed by, and propagated by a religion of judgement, allegation, punishment and exclusion in a real, insidious, self-sabotaging and unsustainable perversion of the original intent of the Jesus of Nazareth. Shedding our dependence on ‘hierarchical superiority’ on any level, whether moral, ethical, religious, political, ideological, economic/fiscal, academic, professional, ethnical, or especially religious is and can be a centre-point of a new era in human spiritual growth and development with the churches as leading role-models.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home