Searching for God # 158
Invoking prophetic voices from the Old Testament, John the Baptist, Leo Tolstoy, as in the last post here, brings the question, “Is anyone, now or in the past, listening, reading, paying attention to and responding to the spoken, written, cried and even sung words of the prophets?” There is a sense of pathos in someone sitting in silence bemoaning the plight, trauma, starvation, disease, forgottenness, homelessness, hopelessness...and even imagining that identification with those ‘on the edge’ is enough to make a difference in their lives. Of course, the voice of the prophet is never precisely targeting the most oppressed, besieged, or desperate; that voice is attempting to ‘move’ those who have previously been inured to and by the plight of the dispossessed, as well as those whose charitable cheques have continued to be deposited into the bank accounts of those selected charities that have already moved them into altruism.
Prophecy and charity are not natural mates. The former irritates, perplexes, sometimes astounds, and even deeply troubles the audience. And therein lies the “rub”....to irritate, to trouble is antithetical to schmooze, to pander and to ‘butter-up’....and we all know that some combination of both uncomfortable and assuaging approaches might have a better chance of ‘moving’ an audience. Incentivizing altruism, social conscience, political activism and thoughtful provocation and discussion through words lies at the core of all social, political, commercial and ‘cause’ communications.
Charity, on the other hand, especially where it reciprocates in tax deductions, has a different quality of experience. It engages, even if vicariously, without ever getting mud on the boots, or breathing the stench of overflowing latrines, or listening to the barely audible cries of hunger from dying children, or witnessing a dead body being removed from a bombed apartment building in Ukraine. Television and print reporters on those scenes represent not only the commitment of their news organizations but the audience ‘back home’ whose perceptions, attitudes and actions might, even indirectly, influence a government, a single benefactor to donate, or another news outlet to underscore the same kind of story.
Prophecy, while perhaps documenting disaster, malicious war-determined slaughter of innocents, brings with it the pathos of the reporter, cameraman and occasionally a human victim. It can also attempt to stretch the conventional envelope of ‘that’s none of my concern’ by attempting to link the deplorable conditions of victims with those closer to the audience. However, linking migrants, refugees, asylum-seekers and IDPs to homeless, chemically dependent, unemployed and hopeless people dying in the streets of North American streets is rarely witnessed. What happens in Gaza, from the perspective of the news editors in North America, has nothing to do with the rising data of homelessness, hopelessness in the streets of Baltimore, for example. The evidence might look similar, but the ‘causes’ and therefore the reasons for reporting or excluding any linkage are considered to be different.
Well...let’s see! Is the blatant, unapologetic, unabashed, insouciance of the power structures in North America to the ravaging of lives in Gaza, Sudan, Ukraine, and elsewhere qualitatively different to the same blatant, unapologetic, unabashed insouciance of the power structures to the lives being ravaged on the streets of North American towns and cities? Similarly, is the need for empathy, compassion, altruism, caring, sensitivity and activism not qualitatively the same as that needed in foreign sites?
In contemporary culture, voices like that of Christopher Hitchens, atheist, have both a podium and an audience. Here is one of his utterances from his own Facebook page:
Beware the irrational, however seductive. Shun the ‘transcendent’ and all who invite you to subordinate or annihilate yourself. Distrust compassion; prefer dignity for yourself and others. Don’t be afraid to be thought arrogant or selfish. Picture all experts as if they were mammals. Never be a spectator of unfairness or stupidity. Seek out argument and disputation for their own sake; the grave will supply plenty of time for silence. Suspect your own motives, and all excuses. Do not live for others any more than you would expect others to live for you.
Rationality is not and need not be antithetical to compassion, or even the transcendent. The very determination and definition of such binary oppositions excludes the relationship of one perspective from another. We are not robots willing and able to be ‘compacted’ into a definition which excludes the transcendent, compassion, empathy and altruism. And no homilies from Hitches and others can or will alter that identity. To reduce the imagination to a programmable algorithm based entirely and exclusively on rationalism, Ayn Rand’s proverbial selfishness as the objective virtue, and the total absence of remorse, empathy, compassion and even pity that bombs its obliteration of innocent others, while not offering a direct ‘cause-effect’ equation, can nevertheless help in explaining the cold, calculating, mean-spirited, vicious, malevolent, malign militarism of rhetoric, perceptions, attitudes and motivations of men like Putin, Netanyahu, Trump, Miller.
And let’s not be blind to the spread of such malignancy, maliciousness, indifference and selfishness that undergird much of what the oligarchs, the despots, the tyrants and the tech giants are doing to the world. It has taken root in the very ghettos where unban politicians have to confront battalions of homeless, street deaths, hungry children needing food programs in order to succeed in school, and street or in-home government abductions of those suspected of illegally living in the U.S.
Prophetic voices have and continue to offer critiques of the most heinous of public attitudes, acts and the results of those acts. Noam Chomsky has, for decades, berated the foreign policy of the United States for being based on lies in too many instances. Scott Peck found no one in the Pentagon following the My Lai massacre who could or would take responsibility for that human desecration. Even Bobby Kennedy and Eugene McCarthy were campaigning for truth-telling about the Vietnam war.
Even reading the tortuous and politically land-mined process of Ruth Bader Ginsberg’s appointment to the bench, in which multiple letters of commendation, rebuttals, political opportunism (race over gender considerations) offers an indisputable narrative of the power of elitism, those insiders in government whose petty prejudices, biases, fettishes, and personal vengeances comprise those ‘landmines’ mentioned. To think or imagine that the processes of the legal fraternity within the confines of its ‘establishment’ rely in the ‘rationality test’ that Ginsberg said was insufficient for deciding gender discrimination cases (the strict scrutiny test was also needed) evaporates like smoke from a beach bonfire. Cronyism, contacts, connections, schmoozing, and even more euphemistic ‘lobbying’ (really leaning on pivotal voices in the decision-making hierarchy) abound in the narrative as reported in her biography.
Power in any organization or profession, or political party or government, or school, college, university or ecclesial body operates on a minimum of two different levels: the formal, organizational chart demands and expectations, and the informal, ‘who-knows-whom' and ‘who-needs-whom' and who-betrays-or abandons-whom' all of this ‘process’ couched in private, secret, unaccountable, often innuendo, gossip, personal ambition, vengeance and delay-to-the-point-of-avoidance of making an appointment/decision/recommendation.
The ‘personal’ highly subjective, informal, unobservable, unreportable, secretive, and often fraught with less than honourable motives is a depiction of much of what we call public policy, public legislation, public debate, professional scholarship and the process of development of the next multiple generations of ‘power-seekers’ whose attitudes and actions will carry the public conscience and public consciousness into the history books.
What chance, if any, has the prophetic voice in such a cauldron of human proclivities? Perhaps it depends on the ‘methods’ of the prophets! A young girl standing in front of the Eiffel Tower in Paris with a sign reading, “The super rich will leave if you tax them”....BULLSH’T...TAX THE RICH!” has more impact than this scribe (now up to 1282 words in this entry today)! She will garner more eyes, minds, hearts, and actions that whatever number of readers cast their eyes on this page.
A podcast with thousands of audience members might have a reach and penetration that a mere blog can expect. A ‘big name’ writer, actor, athlete, investor, inventor, will garner eyes, ears, minds, hearts and actions, especially for the paid purpose of generating sales for some corporation. Indeed, sales (and the profits that ensue) lie at the heart of what we now call unfettered capitalism. And, personal greed, ambition, narcissism and personally assigned impunity along with cozy and private relationships to those in powerful places will prove far more impactful than a few, underpaid, understaffed, idealistic, committed ‘do-gooders’ in an office, for example, of Oxfam International, International Rescue Committee.
To state the obvious, power and status seeks others with power and status; those operating on an idealistic, prophetic, generally underfunded, forever needed and increasingly necessary, profound personal and professional commitments continue to perplex those with power and status. It is as if two different cultures, mind-sets, perspectives, world views and ethical and moral identities operate in parallel, if not opposing, universes. The public, conventional perspective favors the power-and-status success stories while barely acknowledging the work of those prophetic hands, arms, legs, backs, muscles, shoulders, brains and hearts of the compassionate, empathic, idealistic men and women who toil in the shadows of our shared planet.
Occasionally, a news story will flash about a terrorist attack removing hundreds of young girls, for example, and the world will collective, and simultaneously sigh, “Oh my God! What will ‘they’ do next to satisfy their need for power and dominance?” That ‘proverbial “they” are always, indisputable, other human beings with the same flesh, bones, brains, hearts and minds as those of us familiar with these pages.
Their proclivity for violence, abuse, impunity, and their insatiable appetite/need/desperation for power, control and dominance has roots of which we are unfamiliar at least in deta
Far easier it is for us, including this scribe, to identify with a refugee, migrant, asylum-seeking or IDP than it is for me to identify with a Putin, a Netanyahu, a trump or a Kim....Similarly, it is far easier, and more likely for me to identify with a homeless person on the streets of Toronto than with a corporate executive in an Amazon office suite. I cannot and will not attempt to speak for you dear reader; your capacity to identify is likely very different from mine.
Nevertheless, as a collective, a member of a shared social contract it might be that we think we aspire to identify with that corporate executive, when, in our hearts, we know, without ever expressing it to ourselves or to others, that we identify more easily and more readily with the dispossessed than with the powerful.
Is this a game we are playing with ourselves? Thinking that we have more affinity with the rich and powerful than we do with those dispossessed? Are we being, or have we been, seduced by the glossy, hyper-active, super-special-effect-dominated advertising campaigns of products, services, memberships and social goals to which we are told we aspire, all of them funded by billions of dollars and the most highly creative minds available to ‘entertain,’ and to ‘engage’ and to ‘motivate’ each of us to ‘buy’ or ‘travel’ or ‘join’ or ‘invest’ primarily in activities designed to satisfy our personal, often narcissistic, appetites, often based on our unconscious anxieties, apprehensions and fears?
The advertising “prophetic” voices are creative, imaginative, highly funded, highly competitive and possessed of clients of the rich and powerful, whether in the private or public sectors.
The non-profit, idealistic, voluntary, social-justice sectors cannot afford such advertising prophets, with their creative imaginations. Furthermore, those social justice agencies are not ‘selling’ instant gratification, instant appetite soothers, instant power-images of social acceptance, love and personal success. They are promoting a far more painful and growing truth....that millions of huma beings are left voiceless, homeless, hopeless and destitute while the rich continue to carry shiploads of cash to their investment accounts, occasionally writing a cheque for a social justice cause, so they can include their altruism in their corporate advertising.
And we continue to play ‘their game’....all the while knowing, somewhere deep in our hearts, that injustice prevails, inequality reigns, dominance dominates, and ruthlessness rules!
How long can we continue to participate in this charade of self-sabotage, at a universal level?

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home