Tuesday, November 3, 2026

Searching for God # 160

 Something happened to my consciousness recently as I watched a closing sequence to a  movie. An elderly woman was given a painting as part of the delivery of a request from a clergy, with the words, “He wanted it to be back where it belonged, in your family.” She responded gratefully, “Oh thank you; it means so much to me!” 

No art scholar nor critic here, nevertheless, the painting resembled what looked, from a brief glance, rather plain, even ordinarily elemental and somewhat non-descript. What happened for me, however, was as if a light that had been barely shedding light became a little brighter. Of course, we all treasure some things which others could care less about. “One’s junk is another’s treasure,” is a cliche with which we are all familiar. 

It was something else that clamored for attention....that each of us, all the time, without being fully conscious, reflexively, unconsciously and persistently attach, make, understand, glance, imagine, ‘feel’ something, some emotion, attitude, association, projection, resentment, withdrawal, attraction to/from/with/against/for/about whatever ‘stimulus’ (sound, sight, scent, melody, object, image) that ‘slides’ into our ‘brain’ whether for an instant, an hour, an unpacking later, or perhaps forever (in our terms). The short, perhaps for some, clinical expression, is that we are what we perceive.....although such a bumper-sticker reduction seems to miss another aspect of the experience. 

Like an interactive ‘sponge’ absorbing images and mirroring them back to ourselves, whether or not we share our ‘impressions’ with another, we are interacting, physically, psychically, emotionally, perhaps even cognitively, and spiritually in a manner so nuanced, so rapid, so familiar and also so strange as to be only partially aware of what is happening. The experience, in that nano-second is often, if not regularly, regarded as ‘nothing’ or ‘ridiculous’ or ‘inconsequential’ or ‘fleeting’ or ‘of no account’ or ‘startling’ or ‘depressing,’ or ‘infuriating,’ or....or....or.... 

For many, there may be no immediate and overt reaction, perhaps a very slight smile, frown or even a tear; the urgency and timing of any response, however, can be another ‘image’ which others will indubitably also absorb, integrate, ignore, reject, dismiss, ....in what could be considered a never-ending ‘flow’ of random images to which and with which we are all engaged and from which we are evolving. Like tiny organic entities needing nurture (water, sun, warmth, weeding, appreciation) and also needing to witness and integrate moments that deprive of nurture, ignore its relevance, detach from even being noticed....this process continues, perhaps in a parallel manner along with whatever familial formation, formal and informal education, interactions with others outside our circle and whatever formal, designed, professionally delivered ‘stimuli’....all of it, (shifting our metaphor) simmering in the cauldron of our ‘minds’ (not only our brains). 

The romantic poets have been depicted, in and through their poetry, as being and offering both a mirror and a lamp on/to/for the natural world. For sophomores, that twin process indicated that nature had found an imaginative word picture which also offered new light (insight, awareness, depth, emotion, unity) on that set of images in the mirror. The metaphysical poets injected images of physical, concrete things into deep expressions of love where such images seemed incongruous, out of place, and thereby riveting. Dramatists insert into dialogue and stage-presentation both a narrative (Eliot called it the ‘objective correlative) on which they ‘strung’ or ‘hung’ their theme, their dramatic impact and also their reputation. Frye reminds that all literature purports to seek an identity of writer, reader, audience, and universe. Literary imagination uses language of uniting ‘things’ which in their separate space have no relation, the metaphor, the simile, personification. 

For those schooled in the intricacies, nuances and depth of what has already been identified by philosophers, I recognize that my recent experience is nothing more or less than what people like Husserl and Heidegger have termed phenomenology. The above account is merely a kindergartener’s describing an experience, integrated and embraced differently than previously. 

The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (stanford.edu) says this about phenomenology: 

Phenomenology is the study of structures of consciousness as experienced from the first-person point of view. The central structure of an experience is its intentionality, its being directed toward something, as it is an experience of or about some object. An experience is directed toward an object by virtue of its content or meaning (which represents the object) together with appropriate enabling conditions....Phenomenology studies conscious experience as experienced from the subjective or first person point of view. In recent philosophy of mind, the term ‘phenomenology’ is often restricted to the characterization of sensory qualities of seeing, hearing, etc: what is it like to have sensations of various kinds. However, our experience is normally much richer in content than mere sensation. Accordingly, in the phenomenological tradition, phenomenology is given a much wider range addressing meanings things have in our experience, notably, the significance of objects, events, tools, the flow of time, the self, others, as these things arise and are experienced in our ‘life-world’. 

Juxtaposed to the explication of phenomenology, we find this in Hillman’s Re-visioning Psychology: 

Scientific thinking would prefer to resolve all ‘what’s, and why’s too, into how’s. What belongs to the essentialist tradition from Aristotle through Husserl, the father of modern phenomenology. But the psychological what differs even from this background. This difference between phenomenology and archetypal psychology needs clarifying. When we turn to events themselves and let them tell us what they are, our work is phenomenological. And our work is phenomenological when we search for the essence of what is going on in terms of an essential idea or style of consciousness, putting to one side all why’s and how’s. But here our paths part because phenomenology stops short in its examination of consciousness, failing to realize that the essence of consciousness is fantasy images. Archetypal psychology carries the consequences of fantasy through to their full implications, transposing the entire operation of phenomenology into the irrational, personified, and psychopathological domain, a transposition from the logical to the imaginal. Phenomenological reduction becomes an archetypal reversion, a return to mythical patterns and persons. We see through the logical by means of the imaginal; we leave the intentional for the ambiguous. This is what depth psychology has always insisted upon: look at conscious events and intentions from the unconscious, from below. Look at the daylight world from the night side, from fantasy and its archai*. (Re-Visioning Psychology, p. 138-139) (*archai: belonging to an earlier stage of civilization or culture) 

Putting this perspective into context might be helpful. Hillman attempts to do this in these words: 

Ideas left from the days of medical thinking about the psyche still stand as barriers between our symptoms and our souls. Especially stubborn is the idea of treatment. We still think that pathologizing calls for treatment; if not directly a medical treatment then at least psychological. Treatment, of course, assumes that something is wrong---that when the psyche is pathologizing in a fantasy, an emotion, or a symptom this is to be corrected or alleviated by practical measures. Since one tends to find a great deal psychologically ‘wrong’ with oneself and with others, we are engaged in a treatment fantasy during a considerable part of each day. If a friend cannot sleep, and I respond by asking--- ‘What are you doing about it what are you taking for it?’--I am in the treatment fantasy. So, too, when I give myself directions to overcome psychological habits, subdue emotions, or prevent recurring fantasies. One part of myself is treating the other part as patient. By doctoring my sick self, I have plunged head over heels into the medical fantasy. 

The psychological perspective is altogether different. From this viewpoint I am a patient not of my doctor or of the doctor aspect of myself, but of my psyche---a sufferer of it and from it. The soul is the patient of its pathologizing, and I am a patient because my soul pathologizes. Treatment attempts to take away the pathologizing, separating it from soul. ....By searching for the right treatment we literalize pathologizing into its medical meaning. The model in our thought creates the case before us. Thus the idea of treatment as a literal activity would have to be laid aside, for if we are consistent in our thinking there can be no such procedure as ‘psychological treatment.’ The two terms exclude each other; when we are psychological about pathologizing we are not being psychological about it; when we are treating pathologizing we are not being psychological about it. (Hillman, RE-Visioning Psychology, p. 73) 

And Hillman elaborates: 

Let us recall here that psychotherapy, in accordance with the root meaning of the words ‘psyche’ and ‘therapy’ means to serve soul, not to treat it....Serving soul implies letting it rule; it leads, we follow. By following the peculiar disorder activity itself as one of our guides, therapy will have room for the bizarre, decayed, fantastic. As our model of thought is that ‘like has an affinity with like,’ therapy for the abnormal world would have to be abnormal as well.....Since pathologizing is frightening, we are obliged to follow fear, not with courage, but as a path that leads deeper into awe for what is at work in the depths of the soul..... ‘Pathologizing the myth onward’ means staying in the mess while at the same time regarding what is going on from a mythical perspective....By staying with the mess, the morbid, the fantastic, we do not abandon method itself, only its medical model. Instead we adopt the method of the imagination. By following pathologizing onward we are attempting to discover precisely the methods and laws of the imaginal in distinction to the rational and the physical. Madness teaches the method. (Ibid, p. 74-5) 

Recently, in a conversation with our beloved piano tuner, he noted there are two aspects to performing on a musical instrument, specifically referring to the piano. The first is the act of ‘playing’ the notes, the second is the act of ‘listening.’ Here he referred not only to the sound of the instrument but also the ‘sounds’ (vibrations, emanations, auras, and responses) of the audience. The whole experience comprises the ‘moment’ of the encounter. The resonances, however, may not be ‘picked up’ by everyone in the room; indeed, much of the time only the ‘playing’ occurs, sans the ‘listening’. 

The metaphor seems apt after reading Hillman’s words about the process of diving into the ‘mess,’ of an ‘extremis moment’ not to ‘fix it with some intervention but to discover what myth is operating. The ‘literal’ experience of the ‘playing’ on the musical instrument, while perhaps melodious, harmonious and beautifully gratifying and moving, is incomplete without the ‘interactive’ resonating ambience. Similarly, following Hillman, the literal, physical experience is incomplete without the deeper resonance of the full voice of the madness, the mess, and the fantasy it may be unearthing. 

Is there something parallel in much of our theological, spiritual pilgrimmage whereby the literal, empirical ‘playing’ out of our lives has been stripped from the complex, messy, and the fantasical of the imaginal? It says here that much of what passes for the praxis of theology, and religion for many comprises the ‘playing’ without the ‘listening’....and that last concept cannot be contained in the physical, auditory, volume, melodic, dynamic and tone sensitivities. The place where phenomenology seeps into the unconscious, the imagination is not only where archeyptal psychology begins to resonate; it is also, potentially the place where whatever might be considered a relationship with the divine begins to appear (again not in the physical, literal, empirical) but in the imaginal. 

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home