Searching for God # 161
If we start from Robert Funk’s ‘Jesus made no commands,’ and move to a different type of lens through which to contemplate, envision, imagine, reckon with abstract whatever, whomever, wherever, whenever “God” might be (or is) we have several models from various perspectives from which to choose.
Approaching “God” from a perspective of how reason, language, and story-telling conceptualize ultimate reality (From AI) this scribe fits at least partially with the existentialists. Philosophers like Kierkegaard view God not as a logical math problem, but as an absurd, paradoxical reality that requires an emotional leap of faith. (From AI) However, or in addition, there is also what some call a ‘mythological-archetypal lens’. Heavily influenced by literary critic Northrop Frye and psychologist Carl Jung, this approach interprets God as a projection of the universal human psyche. God is analyzed as a cosmic archetype—the Wise Old Man, the Supreme Judge, the Father, or the sacrificial hero—representing human desires, fears and social order. (From AI)
At the core of some ‘mix’ or conflation of existentialist-mythological-archetypal lies the heartbeat of language, including various genres, poetic images, exaggeration, all of them attempts to depict what is inherently ‘indescribable’ ephemeral, ineffable, unknowable...based on an apophatic perception of God. And at the core of that original process, (author, speaker, homilist, religious educator, writer) lies the human imagination. Those who have be predilection, or default, design or accident come to a different way to approach God, called the cataphatic approach focuses on describing God using positive statements and attributes and images.
William Blake’s imaginative ‘conception’ of an androgynous God linked to his interpretation of the Fall consisting of the separation of the male and female genders, of course, falls into the ‘apophatic’ method of imagining the divine as well as the archetypal-mythological lens. Such sweeping, almost ‘revolutionary’ as opposed to ‘evolutionary’ perception/imagination is neither amenable to, nor constricted by anything resembling literal, empirical, historical evidence. And herein lies one of the converging tensions whenever a discussion of theology arises.
Apparently, the question of the historic authenticity of Jesus of Nazareth, formidably and scholarly unearthed over many ‘quest’ projects, including the Jesus Seminar, remains still completely a non-existent entity for some. ‘That the Romans kept very good records,’ as one colleague recently put it, to justify a conviction that Jesus never existed, ‘although his words contain many wonderful ideas, seems, for that person, to have eclipsed the many legitimate, authentic ‘quests’ for the historical Jesus of Nazareth.
Juxtaposing the Blake ‘reading’ of the Fall, with the still extant conviction that Jesus did not exist, posits two very different lenses, the imaginative with the literal-empirical. The God-man dichotomy, too, reaffirms the apparent and alleged paradox of Jesus as a bridge between God and humanity. That Jesus never claimed to be the Son of God, that Jesus was never pronouncing a ‘kingdom’ of his imperial wishes and commands, but rather a vision of a kingdom received from “God” and that Jesus was transformed into the risen Christ, following the Crucifixion and Resurrection, (the latter for which there is no historical evidence, but only metaphoric transformation) and that Jesus was an authentic historic figure...all of this seems to be lost on many.
It is somewhat difficult to discern why contemporary culture has become so engulfed, perhaps even subsumed by the scientific, literal, empirical perspective and assessment of reality. However, the poetic, imaginative, apophatic, ephemeral, ethereal and cosmic perspective seems to find relevance, application and literary receptivity in science fiction. Theology struggles continuously with a tension, often a deep division, between those who insist on retaining the moral commands of the words of a Christ figure as the essence of those teachings, and those whose faith and spirituality seeks to find, to reflect on and to continue to imagine the ‘world’ as a kingdom of God still to be both envisioned and embodied.
The conviction of that colleague, that humans are pack animals, steeped in the inescapable genetic mode of violence and savagery, also betrays human history and especially the scholarship of anthropology that demonstrates a very different conception of humanity. The novel, ‘Lord of the Flies’ by William Golding posits a micro-world of school-boys marooned on an island, who turn to violence only to be ‘rescued’ by a naval ship engaged in the second war, thematically illustrative of the notion that civilization is a thin and fragile veneer, that without structure of laws and authority, human beings naturally regress into savagery and violence. (From AI) Is this allegedly inherent proclivity one of the more popular or universal depictions of ‘evil’? Or, is there contravening evidence and theory and depiction of humanity that warrants revisiting? Is this novel really about The Fall, referenced earlier with Blake?
From the website, unHerd.com in a piece entitled, ‘Lord of the Flies is wrong about humanity We aren’t naturally cruel’ by Terry Eagleton, February 28, 2026, we read:
A lot of us would betray anyone at all to avoid one tongue being chewed by rodents, including the odd babe-in-arms, but to claim that this reveals our ‘real’ self is absurd. The extreme doesn’t necessarily define the norm. The belief that to press someone to their limit is to discover who they are goes hand-in-hand with the equally dubious claim that every-day existence is inherently inauthentic.....Christianity...doesn’t maintain that human beings are irretrievably corrupt, whatever Golding may think. It rejects both the bright-eyed progressive view that we’re naturally selfless and compassionate, but also the sour-faced reactionary case that we’re a bunch of deep-eyed villains who can be saved only by the gratuitous act of divine grace....The very powers which allow is to forge genuine progress (healing the sick, feeding the hungry, and so on) are also the powers which enable us to commit genocide. It is the self-contradictions of the human species that are at stake here. Because we have bodies of a certain kind (labouring, communicative, cooperative, and so on) we can develop technologies far beyond the capability of squirrels. ....The liberal tends to hold that once we’re allowed to be free, our better natures will flourish; the conservative believes that only by the strict application of order and discipline can anything morally valuable be squeezed out of our selfish, indolent make-up. Christianity is both a great deal more pessimistic than the liberal and considerably more optimistic than the conservative.
Reducing this, and other binary, either-or dichotomies to a zero-sum equation, in that if one ‘side’ prevails the other must lose, (and be out of touch with reality) accounts for much of the current vitriol in which the political, social, and economic cultures are drowning. And we are all, by our existence, impaled in the same cultural, linguistic, perceptive and potentially even religious-faith-spiritual swimming pool.
The rejection of formal religion, as has been and continues to be the position of many whose lives have been deeply wounded by the ecclesial establishment, however, need not necessarily be a full divorce, irretrievably and incompatibly irreconcilable with religion. Indeed, just as the absolute separation of church and state both philosophically and pragmatically refuses to be constrained by any law or religious pronouncement, so too the Christian faith cannot be incarcerated in either liberal or conservative ‘cells.’ Similarly, the nature of humanity cannot be reduced to either pack-savage or compassionate-empathic angel.
For what is now beginning to seem like an intuitive magnet, that interpretation of Blake’s on the Fall, about the loss of androgyny, the separation into male and female, represents another of the images that suggest, imply or even motivate to imagine our proclivity, penchant, obsession and active beating-of-the-drums of the literal-binary-empirical definition of reality, not only defies the very subject of our investigation and contemplation, it also defies the limits which do not exist in/of the divine.
Could this obsession with whatever divide we happen to prefer, including whichever ‘side’ we prefer on this or that specific, issue, file or cause, be at the heart of the human repetition of a cycle, like that uroborus snake with its head in its tail, generating endless tensions, conflicts, cultural traditions and obsessions and, effectively imprisoning humanity in a loop of its own perceived, but not literal ‘hard-wiring’?
Are we so engrossed in, imbued with, convicted of and championing some ‘form of right’ as opposed to some ‘form of wrong’ as we universally, predictably and persistently find ourselves metaphorically searching for our ‘identity’ that we are missing the richness the complexity, the nuances and the divine that escapes our partial blindness? Defining that ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ as we all know, intuitively, inescapably and irrefutably, is merely ‘our’ preferential, comfortable, somewhat indoctrinated, somewhat assimilated, somewhat formally imbued through education and experience in our own community’s perception! And that perception is more open to enrichment (many would dub it contradiction) just as is the perception of our most profound enemies’.
In another life, I recall an adult daughter, who had converted to Judaism, commenting, “I really have trouble with Jesus!” as an indicator of part of her shift to her new ‘tribe’. The colleague who denies the historic truth of Jesus existence apparently has a similar ‘problem’ with Jesus. So too, do those who, having spent decades in Christian church pews, (and pulpits and seminaries!) find that their comfort level in, their comportment with and their compliance with the perceptions, conceptions, dogmas and abuses are no longer tolerable. The likelihood of the ecclesial establishment’s transformation into a more authentic, credible, verifiable and motivating faith seems highly unlikely. Shifting participation is another two-headed tidal wave, some marching to the strict order, dogma and structure of Roman Catholicism while others are choosing new movements like the Non-religious Existential Spirituality movement of Jim Palmer. It is not the task or responsibility to assign ‘correctness’ or ‘perfection’ or any hint of divine approval to or for any of the multiple choices, including those of other established world religions.
Suffice it to say that this scribe is increasingly leaning toward a universalist-Christian form of faith emerging from the work of people like Robert Funk in his Honest to Jesus, without seeking to convert or to dismiss anyone from their spiritual, religious faith pilgrimage.
Post script: paradoxically this next piece was written a few days ago, and not posted. It is an attempt to focus my own intuitive, imaginative and speculative reckoning with the many questions within my relationship with the divine.
Sometimes, this slow learner is amazed at just how long it takes for a set of ‘notions’ and ‘ideas’ and ‘perceptions’ and ‘attitudes to crystalize and to find a ‘home’ with others of like mind-heart-spirit-perception.
Robert Funk, in and through his Honest to Jesus, referred to with delight in many posts in this space, offered insights so compelling that I emailed the Weststar Institute to ask if the institute ‘seeded’ any congregations, to which they answered, ‘No, we offer conferences and lectures etc.’
And then, some considerable time after an excursion of some months into the Unitarian Universalist congregation nearby, while struggling with how to ‘incorporate’ Jesus of the Jesus Seminar into a hybrid faith expression, I learned to my surprise, that there are people who consider themselves, “Christian Unitarian Universalists”. Wow! What a thought, what a concept and what a welcome discovery!
Here are a few glimpses of how Funk’s and the Jesus Seminar’s insights are applied:
1: Metaphorical Liturgy: Easter and communion are reframed. Instead of celebrating a literal, bodily resurrection or a substitionary atonement for sin—both of which Funk and UU’s reject-worship focuses on the ‘Living Christ’ as a metaphor for continuous love, hope and renewal within the community.
2: De-mythologizing of Sunday School and Adult Education: Religious education in UU churches leans heavily into biblical criticism. Jesus was a Jew, not a Christian; As UU ministers often highlight in their sermons, educational programs teach children and adults that Jesus had no intention of starting a new church or a religion about himself. He was an out and out Unitarian who believed in a singular unified God. People are encouraged to study the Bible like any other historical text, stripping away the supernatural layers to find the human heart of the story.
3: Jesus as the Prototype for Social Justice Activism: Because Funk’s research frames Jesus as a non-apocalyptic, counter-cultural street sage, UU Christians use his life as a direct blueprint for modern social justice. Challenging the Empire: UUs map Jesus’ defiance of the Roman Empire and rigid religious hierarchies onto contemporary systems of oppression. Radical Inclusivity: Funk’s portrait of a Jesus who practiced ‘radical generosity’ by eating with outcasts and economic causalities directly inspires UU ministries centered of wealth redistribution, sheltering the unhoused, and defending marginalized communities. For modern UU Christians, applying Funk’s ideas means rescuing Jesus from the status of an institutionalized ‘icon’ and reclaiming him as a fellow religious liberal, progressive seeker, and social activist.
And quoting an archived sermon entitled, “Honest to Jesus: The Gospel According to Funk”:
Jesus was arguably the first stand-up comic, a brilliant street fighter, a lethal wit...He was a radical social critic who went out of his way to side with the poor, the marginalized and the outcasts...The sermon concludes by challenging the congregation to live out Funk’s 21st thesis: moving away from a religion about Jesus and moving toward the religion of Jesus. The minister tracks how ancient politics at the Council of Nicea turned a radical, system-flapping rebel into a passive ‘icon’ used to support empires. By stripping that away, the sermon challenges UU Christians to do what Jesus actually did: practical radical hospitality, speak truth to power, and build the ‘kingdom of God’--which Funk defined not as a place in heaven but as a way of practicing unconditional love on earth. (From AI)
So, what are the thoughts and images that spring to mind to begin a process to which Funk counsels his readers:
In articulating the vision of Jesus, we should take care to express our interpretations in the same register as his employed in his parables and aphorisms. Jesus quite deliberately articulated an open-ended, nonexplicit vision in his parables. He did not prescribe behavior or endorse specific religious practices. He was never programmatic in his pronouncements. His followers had and have the obligation to transmit his tradition in the same key. It is perfectly acceptable to specify what his pronouncements may mean for our time and place, but it is not commensurate with his vision to chisel them in stone. Our interpretation of parables should be more parables---polyvalent, enigmatic, humorous, and nonprescriptive. Yet we are invited by his example to be equally bold and innovative. (Funk, Honest to Jesus, Thesis #7, p 305)

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home