Searching for God # 162
The Jewish historian, and visionary prophet, Yuval Noah Harari, in his '21 Lessons for the 21st century,' in a chapter entitled 'God, Don't take the name of God in vain,' writes some cogent, poignant, and compelling insights about the third commandment.
The third of the biblical Ten Commandments instructs humans never to make wrongful use of the name of God.....Perhaps the deeper meaning of this commandment is that we should never use the name of God to justify our political interests our economic ambitions, or our personal hatreds. People hate somebody and say, 'God hates him'; people covet a piece of land and say, 'God wants it.' The world would be a much better place if we followed the third commandment more devotedly. You want to wage war on your neighbours and steal their land? Leave God out of it and find yourself some other excuse. (p.202)
It is not only the gap between the literal, infantile, 'don't use God's name in vain,' that means no swearing, no cussing, no foul language, and no embarrassment for the parents, teachers, coaches and all mentors of children and the light Harari shines on the third commandment that warrants a literal affirmation. It is the perspective that accompanies his view that warrants a closer look.
The literal textualists, whether in biblical interpretation, or in the perception and interpretation of what comprises reality that persists on the literal, empirical, lens through which to identify, assess, discern, judge and then intervene from the premise of that perspective that has haunted this scribe for decades.
Why is this so irritating?
In the first place, there are so many ideas, concepts, words, notions that we throw around as if we presume that whomever we might be speaking with has the same interpretation and definition and meaning of the words we are using as we do.
Just yesterday, on CNN's The Lead with Jake Tapper, I listened to a retiring congressman from Texas, Republican I believe, who, when asked about the "war" in Iran, and the president's not having sought Congressional approval and permission, responded by saying, "What is a war? The Supreme Court will have to rule or the Congress will have to define what a war actually is!" Somewhat surprised, Tapper asked, words to the effect of, ‘well, we took military action against Iran, is that not a war?'
The conversation and the listeners were left hanging with the allegedly open-ended question of both what is a war and who is going to define it? At the same time, there were likely fewer than the number of fingers we each have on both hands in the audience who would have some 'confusion' about what a war is. Bombs, missiles, drones, blocked ships, threats to 'annihilate' the nation of Iram spewed from a public microphone by one serving as the Commander in Chief of the most vaunted, most heavily funded, and allegedly most technically and strategically advanced military behemoth in history still, for this Republican were not enough to define 'war'?
Is this linguistic silliness reminiscent of the meaning of 'is' in the long-forgotten Clinton investigation. Does 'is' mean at this moment, in the present tense, or does 'is' mean 'is and never has been'....comprises what has become known as the semantic defence, arguing over the literal and temporal definitions of words. From Slate, in a piece entitled Bill Clinton and the Meaning of "Is", September 13, 1998, we read:
The distinction between 'is' and 'was' was seized up on by the commentariat when Clinton told Jim Lehrer of PBS right after the Lewinsky story broke, 'There is no improper relationship.'....This is way beyond slick. Perhaps we should start calling him, 'Existential Willie.'
Those responsible for the Russian illegal, unjustified 'war' against Ukraine, would welcome such a 'slick' literal, superficial and abominable 'semantic' defense, perhaps by declaring that, "We are only responding to the drones, bombs, missiles that have been dropping on our nation from Ukraine"....as in transferring all responsibility for the heinous, criminal and illegitimate violence being inflicted on the nation of Ukraine for the past five years, with little if any hope of termination.
In fact, it was the pseudo-diplomat, Jared Kushner, who recently uttered another ridiculous perspective about any potential 'peace' in this conflict....."it must be a 'win-win' for both sides...it must give Putin some of his aspirations!” How absolutely specious, irresponsible and totally disclosive of the incestuous relationship between the trump administration and the Kremlin...To declare from the public podium, as the official representative of the United States of America, that a war inflicted unilaterally, unprovoked, and unjustified, (except in the mind of Putin's paranoia about the presence of NATO on his border) needs to be resolved in a win-win proposition.
Is this the precise polar opposite of the 'zero-sum' game the trump administration has been deploying against any real, or perceived or anticipated 'enemy' within the borders of the USA' for the purposes of attempting to justify the most inhumane, irrational, insensitive and even lethal methods merely to accomplish the obvious goal of political elimination. A former Russian professor (Anthony Ramunas) once described, in a single word to his class in Comparative Education at the University of Ottawa, the Russian method of solving problems, "Elimination!"
And that was not intended as a 'semantic defence.' The difference between an accepted, conventional, somewhat precise ‘picture’ or word identification of reality and the highly parced and also parched notion that an American retiring Congressman cannot and will not agree to when it comes to the meaning of “war” is a chasm wider than the Grand Canyon. And the linguistic divide represents, mirrors, and even inflates the divide of political parties, ideologies, theologies and personal as well as professional relationships.
The Christian church has promulgated, taught and endoctrinated millions of people with too many literalisms. And some of the implications of that ‘literalism’ are being exposed by Christian scholars.
Only recently, New Testament scholar and former Anglican bishop, N. T. Wright, speaking at Park Cities Baptist church in Dallas, as reported on Eric Holmberg’s Facebook page, challenged one of the most deeply entrusted assumptions of American evangelism: that the modern State of Israel represents the fulfilment of biblical prophecy. Wright called that belief ‘a totally unbiblical idea,’ describing its theological foundations as ‘simply unwarranted. He traced much of its popularity to nineteenth-century dispensationalism*, warning that ‘the chickens are coming home to roost’ and that it is a very dangerous thing to believe. But Wright didn’t stop there. Addressing Romans 11:26 - ‘And so all Israel will be saved,’- he rejected the popular dispensationalist expectation of a dramatic, last-minute conversion of ethnic Israel. Asked whether Paul was speaking of the Church, composed of believing Jews and Gentiles united in Christ, Wright answered simply, ‘Yep that’s what he means.’....
*Dispensationalism is a Christian theological framework for interpreting the Bible that views human history as divided into distinct administrative periods or ages (called dispensations) during which God tests humanity under different responsibilities. Core principles: literal interpretation: it applies a consistent, normal, historical-grammatical method of reading Scripture, especially regarding unfulfilled prophecies....Because of its strict literal reading or prophecy and the distinction between Israel and the church, dispensationalism typically leads to: Premillennialism: the belief that Jesus Christ will return physically to Earth before setting up a literal 1,000-year kingdom. Pre-tribulation Rapture: the belief that believers will be caught up to heaven before a future seven-year period of global tribulation. Christian Zionism: A strong emphasis on the ongoing national and geographic significance of the modern Jewish people and the land of Israel....the system was largely systematized in the 1830’s by John Nelson Darby and the Plymouth Brethren, and later popularized in the United States through the Scofield Reference Bible. (1909) (FromAI)
Systems of belief become coagulated around a single, easily digestible, easily propagated and also unfortunately also easily embraced and accepted as “gospel” when they are often, as in the case of dispensationalism, highly erroneous.
If you are wondering why so much space and time, here, is being dedicated to the issue of dispensationalism, it is because this scribe is shedding one of the most heinous and also most deeply memorized lessons from Sunday School back in the 1950’s in a church in which biblical literalism, including dispensationalism, was theological doctrine. I can see the ‘choir room,’ and the then instructor, an earnest, deeply committed ‘born again’ industrial businessman, seated behind a simple desk on a simple wooden chair, uttering these lessons to a band of some dozen innocent young minds. I had very uncomfortable sensations then, and today I know more fully why.
Another welcome ‘shedding’ is found in the contextualizing of William Blake’s imaginative interpretation of the Fall, as the separation from androgyny into male and female with the textual literalisms that offer biblical justifications for literalists to oppose the LGBTQ+ community.
Similarly, the use of biblical quotes to justify the anti-abortion position pale when contextualized with the ethical arguments of bodily autonomy, gender equality and social justice and moral agency, not to mention reproductive health and safety.
Finally, a few words from the Canadian author, Hugh MacLennan, from Two Solitudes, a novel depicting the French-English tension in Canada:
Marx is only half right when he calls religion the opium of the people. It may turn a lot of people into sheep, but it turns far too many of them into tigers.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home