Attemtping to reconcile with self
How does one reconcile with one’s own history, biography, and the pain one has indisputably inflicted on others? Or does one? None of us on this day can say that we have not been hurt and also that we have inflicted deep and profound pain, perhaps even life changing wounding, on others...and on others who were very close, important and even cherished. Recognizing our own pain brings us even closer to the pain we know we have inflicted. The notion that ‘people need people’ is valid and authentic not only in the manner in and by which others support and love, but even more importantly, in the opportunity their presence cannot be denied, avoided, discarded, dismissed or extricated from our own story. And that presence is simply inescapable, reminding us of our ‘dark side’ irrepressibly.
Is it that we expect too much of those close to us, family members, with whom we naively construe and construct impossible fantasies only to experience the crashing fall when those fantasies collapse right before our eyes? And while we can see ‘their’ part in that crash, are we even conscious of our own half of the equation? As children, we were untutored in the nuances of adult attitudes, perceptions, beliefs and especially motivations. Our parents, while claiming to love us, paradoxically presented words, sounds, sighs, frowns, and sadly even actions that seemed to bely their love. “Spare the rod and spoil the child” may have underlain some of their determination to raise ‘good’ children. Competition with neighbouring parents, never acknowledged, and would have been denied if suggested, might have lurked in the shadows of some parents’ minds. Social ambition, to be attained in and through the ‘accomplishments’ of the child, may also have lingered in the background of those parents’ unconscious. Expectations, even those that have perceptible benchmarks, are not only warranted, but necessary for all young people. The manner in which those expectations are implemented, imposed, sanctioned rewarded, however, is a very different matter. Vicarious yet unfulfilled personal ambitions projected onto a child, without the child’s awareness that such a projection might be possible and happening, carry with them dissonant vibrations and resentments for which the child has no explanation and which may become clarified only decades later.
In short, the poverty of personal experience is at least one source of the poverty and pain inflicted through projections onto the next generation. And that observation cannot and must not serve as excuse, justification or release from the responsibility that the child, now turned adult and parent, inflicts on the child. In short, a child angry and confused about the anger and confusion of the parent may unconsciously repeat the pattern, with his/her own children and spouse. And that observation is never to be considered a rationalization for the now adult/parent second-generation abuse.
Such preamble, however, may do more to contextualize the guilt, shame and loss for the offending second-generation adult/parent, than it could possibly serve as comfort or even reasonable explanation for the wounded and scarred children of the second generation. Nothing, literally nothing, can or will ever heal the open emotional, intellectual, psychic, social, and perhaps even physical and spiritual, wound left with the second-generation children. Talk therapy, irrespective of the specific modality, can never recover the time lost, the words never spoken, the shared milkshakes never enjoyed, the graduations or marriages never attended, nor the birthdays, graduations and accomplishments of the children of the second generation. Those compounded losses have a far greater impact than might be sought by and through any charge of self-pity against this scribe, that listing those losses might evoke.
Loss has so many faces, some of which come to us without our knowing participation and also without our anticipation. Death of a parent, a spouse, a close friend...they all leave an emotional hole, a kind of scar, for which there is no band-aid, no medical procedure, no anesthetic and no painkiller. Just as for divorce there is no formal ‘funeral’ ritual, (although such rituals have been both written and performed) so too there is no ‘literal’ or analogic funeral for what amounts to the termination of a close family relationship. The victims of the abandonment, the betrayal and the wounding are likely never to understand or appreciate even the slightest emotion, thought, perception, attitude or conviction of those who leave. Similarly, the adult who abandons will never know the depth of the wounds s/he may have inflicted. Silence reigns in the vacuum left by the rupture. The cliche that silence may be the most penetrating and lasting of communications, filled as it is with memory, sadness, guilt, remorse and the powerlessness to recover the losses or heal the wounds, seems to apply.
However, let us not get trapped into inferring that there is an equal or even a comparable equation between the grief and loss suffered by the abandoned children and the loss self-inflicted on/by the withdrawn, now disgraced, former parent. The latter pales in comparison with the former.
All this heady intellectualizing about some abstract hypothetical scenario, however, cannot and will not cover over the facts, surgically remove the record, or exonerate the agent of abandonment for the choices s/he made.
And that is why this is personal.
There are no account books, and no penitential prayers, and no compensation payments, and no face-to-face even professionally supervised conversations that can or will ‘make up’ for the losses suffered by abandoned adolescent children who did nothing to ‘deserve’ or to cause or to explain their experience.
There is only an authentic offering of remorse, shame, guilt and the ensuing decades of self-reflection. There is also the learning and the glimmers of light that have flickered in a silent and private way within the darkness. Blaming others, including the actions of parents, as a sure sign of projection of my own shadow onto those others, is inescapable. Continuing that ‘blame others’ approach, however, is patently hollow and of no sustaining resilience. Attempting to rationalize the scarcities and poverties of others deflects from and distracts from any and all attempts to confront the facts. And the facts, while despicable and deplorable on their own merit, were not then or are not now the final definition of this betrayer. My identity is not enclosed in my worst decisions, nor is it enclosed for any others. My worst decisions remain, in many cases, in a vacuum of undelivered, unuttered amends to those whom I have wounded.
This page is inadequate to contain the depth and number of apologies, amends, which I owe to those I have hurt. As is likely the case with many, the depth of any hurts that we have inflicted remains elusive and beyond the full weight of direct, personal experience. It is only through intuition, imagination and empathy that even a glimpse or metaphorical hematoma of the impact can be conceived. Nor does a single page suffice to expiate the wrongs I have inflicted.
Perceiving and intuiting that the estrangement I initiated has been so wounding of the victims, I have attempted only infrequent and tepid attempts at reconciliation. Add the conviction that to force such an attempt would only open and fester already partially healing wounds. All signs of any feasible encounters even being envisioned, never mind enacted, have never really appeared on my radar.
Finally, while acknowledging that these moments of tapping the keys on the laptop have been exposing what I consider my most significant vulnerability, I also am grateful for the opportunity finally to have taken the time for this purpose. Some readers may be willing to receive, tolerate and perhaps even embrace this rather lame and sincere ‘amends’: others cannot and will not. Reconciling with others does indeed pale beside attempting to reconcile with oneself. The process, reflection, anticipation of and ultimate failure to reconcile is itself a process that stretches, rumbles, roils and resurges almost like acid reflux throughout one’s life. The losses remain; their imprint follows the rhythms and the vagaries of all of those rumbles, roils and refluxes.
A different perspective on the absentee father and what calls him away is found in Hillman’s borrowed quote from Rilke:
Sometimes a man stands up during supper
and walks outdoors and keeps on walking,
because of a church that stands somewhere in the East.
And his children say blessings on him as if he were dead.
And another man, who remains inside his own house,
dies there, inside the dishes and the glasses,
so that his children have to go far out into the world
toward that same church, which he forgot.
(from The Soul’s Code, by James Hillman, p. 81-82, from Rainer Maria Rilke, Selected Poems of Rainer Maria Rilke, trans. Robert Bly (New York, Harper and Rowe, 1981)

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home