Searching for God # 163
Having referred to the Tolstoy interpretation of the Sermon on the Mount, as the vision of non-violently confronting evil with force, this scribe cannot avoid the inherent question: what is evil?
The subject has both confounded, as well as convicted, many with its subtlety, complexity, ubiquity, persistence, and also its intimate relationship with both God and the world religions. And to be blunt, we are all conflicted about the ‘nature of evil’ as well as about our many layered responses to it. Banned books, banned because some ‘religious’ ecclesial authority considered them ‘evil’ often had, in the past, been intensely focused on and concerned with the ‘corruption’ of youthful minds about sex. Prurience, a morbid or excessive interest in sexual matters, or a tendency toward lewd, lustful thoughts and desires, has, for many, qualified as a ‘lens’ for deciding which books warranted remaining on secondary school curricula. The writers of those books may very well have held a much more artistic, even idealistic, loving and perhaps even platonic perception of and attitude to sex. Whether ‘sex’ is ‘evil’ is a question that has plagued civilization for centuries, with so many ramifications, criminal charges, and social degradations of individuals as to be innumerable.
Yuval Noah Harari writes in, 21 Lessons for the 21st Century, (p298):
The problem with evil is that in real life it is not necessarily ugly. It can look very beautiful. Christianity knew this better than Hollywood, which is why traditional Christian art tended to depict Satan as a gorgeous hunk. That is why it is so difficult to resist Satan’s temptations. That is also why it is difficult to deal with fascism......
Although gigantic issues like war, slavery, the abuse of power, covetousness, vengeance, even more subtle issues like colonialism racism, sexism ageism, all subsets of the abuse of power, have all been categorized as evil, nevertheless, they are all still rampant everywhere. More recently, having witnessed the ‘wrapping’ of power in the sanctimonious and conventional exchange of business, money, and all that money will buy, including the political, ideological, sycophancy of men and women who offer their names for political office, whether appointed or elected, some have come to regard money and the obsessive acquisition and hoarding, parading, vaunting and the ostentatious display of it as “evil”. We can point, measure and calculate and allegedly trace, follow and read the movement of money, as a barometer of behaviour. Indeed, so seductive is the lure of filthy lucre that it has been immortalized in scripture, literature and conventional public opinion.
And yet, given the alleged roots of our ‘economic’ template, to which the developed world has become both tolerant and even idolatrous, millions of lives are consumed by and in the pursuit of some various sizes of stashes of cash. Whether in a street market in Morocco, where customers barter for the price of a silk garment, and the sellers and creators see a minimal margin of profit, or on Wall Street, where, “Greed is good!” became a bumper-sticker slogan in the movie of that name, money and its ‘benefits’ dominate domestic, political, corporate and government perceptions, attitudes, analyses and decision-making. Not to mention the media coverage of those dyamics!
And while money and its flow are observable, to some extent, the transfer of large amounts from ‘anonymous’ sources, donors, lobbyists, even international investors and more recently ‘crypto-greedsters’ has brought on another layer of obfuscation, elevating deception, avoiding and invalidating and effectively obviating the rule of law as another layer of the insidious and seductive-obsessive pursuit of mountains of money. So, which is more insidious and ‘evil’: the lure of lucre or the deception of its infiltration into the lives of men, women, organizations, and even nations? Evil’s face acquires new, more deceptive and cunning cover-ups as the flow of large rivers of money appears to ‘surge’ into the accounts, portfolios and sunny island estates of billionaires and even trillionaires. And the result is another legal, political and conventional depiction of another manifestation of the dangers of too much money, the escape from and avoidance of any form of accountability, transparency and public trust.
Harari’s observation that evil is often highly attractive, even seductive, is both appropriate and obvious.
And, to think, or worse, to believe that legal documents, commandments, sanctions, prosecutions, and convictions are individually or certainly not collectively, going to moderate, minimize, ameliorate, or eliminate the idolatrous affinity, insatiable appetite, and psychological obsession for the acquisition of money is sheer madness. Legal systems including the laws passed by legislatures, and investigated by law enforcement and prosecuted by courts, judges, magistrates at all levels, have become so bereft or so complicit or so ineffectual that in too many western countries the vast proportions of wealth have surreptitiously slid into the ‘hands’ of the very few.
So, now is the evil the pursuit of money, or the obfuscation of what men and women are doing with it, or the much broader issue of economic policy, tax policy, social justice policy and the common-sense element of fairness. Some point to the hubris of those with either or both fiscal power or political power as an obvious evil. Some point to the political/fiscal incest between the two, those with the fat wallets and those casting the votes in legislatures. Others, like Greta Thunberg, declare their intent to bring capitalism to its knees. Others point to the rampant, wanton, irresponsible, savage and deliberate devastation of the environment by behemoth polluting corporations, particularly the fossil fuel industry. Once again, however, that charge can also be laid at the feet of a green broke business model. Not only is the model unfettered, as some have deduced, others say it is completely rabid. When dogs get rabies, we have to take serious, immediate steps to attack the condition. For rabid capitalism, it would seem that we still have to resort to the ‘vote’ by the wider electorate, given that we cannot rely on the votes of legislators who can plainly see the growing even seismic gulf between the rich and the poor.
And yet, much propagandizing, paid for by the fat wallets, informs, shapes, and even inculcates/infests the ethos, the culture, the collective mind-set, including the collective unconscious with the “values” of getting rich, generating more and more billionaires, even trillionaires, as a benchmark for the success of the ‘system.’ The American Supreme Court, in Citizens United has declared money for political campaigns, irrespective of its source, is “free speech”. And who in this world of contemporary America is not aware that ‘free speech’ is not only a ‘freedom’ but an actual ‘idol’ in the American culture? It too is worshipped, virtually without boundaries, and permitted free-rein, analogous to another green-broke horse.
So, is there another lens to highlight what might be going on in the American/Western social, economic, political, international trade gestalt? Some might argue that personal greed lies at the core of the ‘way things operate’ and the argument that seeding ‘greed’ as a ‘good’ in the minds and ambition of generations of young people will continue to ‘feed’ the systems of the next several generations.
Is that proposition even sustainable? Does that proposition even pretend to support, embrace, recognize and take responsibility for those whom everyone can see are victims of this new iteration of oppression? Of course not! And so, if the prosecution of individuals, and the proposals of legislation and the investigations of corruption have failed to provide, enforce and inculcate the need for legitimate boundaries around the ‘capitalist’ behemoth, all of them directed to the malfeasance of individual persons, (even corporations are legally considered ‘persons’ in American law) how, in our wildest fantasies can we expect any transformation in the literal scorched earth existence into which millions are falling?
Just as Scott Peck discovered when investigating the My Lai massacre, no person was responsible for the wanton deaths of Vietnamese...decision-making by committee effectively exonerates all....or eliminates scrutiny, accountability, transparency and both guilt and shame...But just as the Ontario government under Mike Harris offloaded the costs of what previously were provincial responsibilities onto the towns and townships, the ‘establishment’ has found ways to subvert the formation of unions, the attractiveness (adaptability, manipulation) of part-time workers, (no benefits, no pensions, no obstructions to firings) and also championed the rising tide of single entrepreneurs as a ‘victory’ for capitalism (in its micro form), the ‘system’ has been so mis-shaped as if it had been administered an overdose of a horrendous drug, thalidomide. Only in this instance, the drug was engineered, (social engineering) to generate generations of capitalist clones who abhor government regulations and virtually genuflect to their guns and to those legislators who ‘bow the knee’ in support.
So, once again, what is the evil? Is it the obsession for personal, clique, insider, gated, legally purchased absolute control of money, social and political levers of power, propaganda machines, and effectively the mind-control of the masses? Or, conversely, is it the complicity of the masses to have willingly, obligingly, even enthusiastically drunk the koolaid, to the degree that a felon businessman was permitted to morph into the projected image of the nation that the majority wanted, needed and were happy to elect?
And then the question might be, what ‘lack’ absence, hollowness, or obstruction in perception and discernment permitted such a development. It was, centuries ago, Augustine that uttered the notion that evil was effectively the absence of good....and of course, the Christian legacy of that statement is embodied in the ‘fallen man’ interpretation of the Garden of Eden, enhanced, supported and propagated by his heinous ‘sperm’ infestation of succeeding generations.
The most recent utterance of the oval-office-occupant, to the effect that “we make money” in and through wars, is not only so reprehensible but also declares an absolute surrender of all other values, interests, needs, aspirations to the proposition of making more and more and more money. From a lay person’s perspective, this statement, both as a personal idol and as public and national policy is at least indicative of addiction, that condition in which something ‘has taken control of the ‘person’ to the degree that they can no longer function effectively.
Retreat programs for substance or behaviour addicts have limited success. Honourable, worthy and indispensable however, there are definitely limits to their effective application. Some people are unable to adapt, while others, heroically, abstain from their dependency for the rest of their lives.
Again, another question that it seems we all share: Do we collectively need to take a bifocal approach, not only to the individuals in need but also to the culture, the ethos, the anima mundi, (borrowed from Hillman) and begin to conceptualize how sick is the society we have collectively generated? Is the church culpable in having focused on private/personal/ isolated sin for centuries, to the avoidance of both its own culture and the wider, broader, shared, collective? Also, is there an overlap of blindness, ignorance, avoidance, unconsciousness not only in individual lives but also in the application of that model to the culture?
From the British Psychological Society (explore.bps.org.uk) in an essay entitled, “Jung and the Collective Unconscious,” by David Fontana, (https://doi.org/10.5384/bpstran.2007.11.1.42) we read a quote from Jung:
(Jung says of the collective unconscious that it represents a boundless expanse full of unprecedented uncertainty, with apparently-no above and no below, no here and no there, no mine and no thine, no good and no bad. It is the world of water. Where all life floats in suspension; where-the soul of everything living begins; where I am indivisibly this and that; where I experience the other in myself and the other-then-myself experiences me.....
Everyone recognizes that the academic world tends to dismiss, or at least downgrade Jung’s psychology for several reasons; individuals behave differently from groups; a metaphoric theory does not and cannot withstand the rigours of empirical research; such a metaphoric theory has been considered more of metaphysical philosophy that science. Nevertheless, there is a bottom-line meme, thread, or image that our psyche (both individual and collective) ‘has’ both a portion of which we are able to speak, from our thoughts, feelings, perceptions, and another ‘portion’ which tends to elude our sensate, conscious rational ability to express it. Jung’s theory, from a lay perspective (this scribe is not pretending to be a Jungian scholar, analyst, therapist or even a well-read amateur) seems to suggest that there are some ‘patterns’ to our thought, behaviour, attitudes that differ from those patterns which we have experienced directly, been taught and embraced. Whether we prefer to call those patterns ‘archetypes’ and, following James Hillman, attempt to appropriate the names of Greek gods or goddesses, or merely to begin to notice their unplanned, almost usurping eruptions in unwelcome comments at inappropriate moments, or images that arrest our conscious awareness as coming from ‘out of the blue’ or, perhaps as an analogy, in our dreams in which we are not in control yet images appear as if from ‘nowhere’.
Paradoxically, if we concede, for a moment, that much of North America is fixated on the acquisition of money and its further acquisitions, in our shared conscious minds, we might be willing to ask is there some common ‘image’ in our shared unconscious that might be ‘animating’ this drive. Could it be an image of a royal court over which we imaginatively preside? Or could it be an unrecognized, somewhat retiring and whispering fear that we are not, cannot be and never will be ‘enough’? Of course there are other possibilities. Might we unconsciously envision ourselves as conquering heroes of armies of soldiers, ships, aircraft, or even digitally-operated drones, deeply engrossed in an imaginative combat and successfully eliminating the weapons of our opponents? Or might we be imbued with an image of an historic, legendary romantic hero, male or female, fully engaged in one of the many iterations of a love relationship? Carrying the latter image even further, could we also be “seeing” without being conscious of them, images of heroic, legendary romantic love relationships running afoul of some unimagined relationship shoal or storm, the origins of which escape our conscious minds?
Similarly, could the collective of which we are apart, also operate on the levels of daily, hourly news reports of measles outbreaks, or tariffs, or reports of wars, famine, ebola outbreaks, and stock numbers? While at the same time, unbespoken of, and unshared, and even perhaps too painful even to be dragged up out of the depths, could there be very different and even opposing images ‘gurgling’ in our unconscious of which we are unaware. And we remain unaware unless and until we might begin to wonder, ‘is there something wrong with this picture?’ or ‘why am I feeling so isolated from what I perceive to be the conventional perceptions, attitudes, beliefs and approved and tolerated actions of my country, or family?’ Or perhaps, an uneasiness might creep into our bodies without any symptoms of flu, cold, nausea, or headache, as if the body were attempting to ‘ask’ ‘what is out of sorts in this moment’? And analogy might be the hidden awareness of a dog for the potential arrival of his mentor, or similarly an anxious yelp seemingly out of nowhere demonstrating a dog’s sixth sense of some impending trauma.
The concept or notion that, just as a human psyche can be suffering, Hillman posits the idea that a society too can be in psychic pain, and through an imaginative speculation as to what might be ‘ailing’ it, depriving it of is animation, energy, beauty, might thereby be enabled to name its ‘image’ or archetype that is ‘obstructing’ its full life. And, rather than moralize about the person who is doing wrong, and then apply the ‘full force of the law’ to that malfeasance, perhaps first gain some imaginative ‘grasp’ (not cognition, not affective clarity, nor moral judgement) of some of the dynamics that might have overtaken the collective psyche. Perhaps to imagine, as a child would, the world animated as through only a child’s imagination can ‘see’ it, we might borrow that lens, for the purpose of intuiting those dark forces that might be clouding a more ‘sunny’ ethos, even if the face-to-face encounter with our shared ‘obstruction or demon’ is needed first.
The Greek word, hamartia, is defined as ‘missing the mark’ associated as it is with both Greek tragedy and Christian theology. One appropriate question we might all begin to ask, is: How might we be missing the mark of our own healthy, animated, beautiful and creative ethos, culture, or anima mundi, with a view to unearthing what might be barely beneath the surface of our unconscious, and might be so ubiquitously shared it would shock us to learn, potentially that we share both our angst and our image of a healthy soul in the society.
Just perhaps, the literal, empirical, medical, legal scientific template for discerning and assessing reality leaves some significant openings and opportunities for a different lens, in and through the poetic imagination.

0 Comments:
Post a Comment
Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]
<< Home